Funding Voter Verifiable Paper Ballots

Funding Requirement for SB392/HB18 in the FY09 Budget
 October, 2007

  • Current cost estimates for a transition to an optical scan voting system are approximately $36 million.1 The Maryland Election Integrity Coalition disputes these figures. 

  • We believe that purchase of the system authorized in SB392/HB18 will require a FY2009 capital outlay of less than $500,000 (split between the state and counties). 

  • This analysis is based upon a negotiated trade-in / buy-back agreement, for current inventory, that is equivalent to the offer that Diebold Election Systems, Inc. (DESI) made to Alameda County, California, in 2006.2 

  • DESI3 is contractually obligated to provide Maryland with the best price offered to any other customer.4

  • With the transition from current inventory levels of approximately 20,000 voting units to a purchase of 2,000 precinct-based optical scanners and 2,000 ballot marking devices, the state and counties will have an 80% reduction in voting units. This will result in significant and long term cost reductions for state and local election administration. 

  • These administrative cost savings will more than compensate for the initial capital outlay. There will be an immediate reduction in state budget requirements.


1 Fiscal and Policy Note (Revised), SB392; exhibit 2, pg. 8 [LINK]

2 “Election Voting Systems: Analysis of Options.” May 15, 2006. County of Alameda Registrar of Voters. pp. 21-24. [LINK]

3 Diebold Election Systems became Premier Election Solutions on August 16, 2007. [LINK]

4 “Request for Proposals: Direct Recording Electronic Voting System and Optical Scan Absentee Voting System For Four Counties. Project No. SBE-2002-01. Maryland State Board of Elections.” p. 7 [LINK]

     NEXT